Use the link below to share a fulltext version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Pdf stoic cosmopolitanism and zenos republic john sellars. Pragmatic pluralism denotes a particular approach to problems of international human rights and protections that departs from conventional cosmopolitan approaches. Stoic cosmopolitanism should not be taken to imply that the ideal human society resembles a beehive, where individuality is subsumed for the benefit of the group. A person who adheres to the idea of cosmopolitanism in any of its forms is called a cosmopolitan or cosmopolite. She is a kantian, and made the point that kant is a type of stoic, in that he recognizes the need to act according to reason in ethics rather than be influenced by our emotions. Louis according to ancient stoics, a polis is a place, a system of human beings, or both of these things,2 and it is a system of human beingsnot just a loose collectionbecause it is put in order by law. The stoics are admired for being the first in the west to have drawn this conclusion. On cosmopolitanism and forgiveness jacques derrida download. Kant s theory of cosmopolitan right is widely viewed as the philosophical origin of modern cosmopolitan thought.
Pragmatic pluralism argues for situated and localized forms of cooperation between state and nonstate actors, particularly religious groups and organizations, that may not share the. Following the thinking of stoic cosmopolitanism, which went from the stoics, through kant, to secretarygeneral kofi annan, one can say that a global community is both possible and emerging. Globalization, cosmopolitanism, and personal identity tom g. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. University of groningen six varieties of cosmopolitanism. A standard narration has emerged, which depicts western cosmopolitan. Kant and stoic cosmopolitanism free download as pdf file. I use classical cynicism as the primary example of therapeutic cosmopolitanism. Hegels critique of kant s theory of cosmopolitan right, by contrast, is usually viewed as regressive and nationalistic in relation to both kant and the cosmopolitan tradition.
First, in one important sense, it is a version of cosmopolitanism that is grounded particularly in the concept of basic human rights, which demarcates it from other versions of cosmopolitan ethics or moral philosophy, e. Pdf on dec 10, 2010, adam etinson and others published cosmopolitanism. Drawing on the work of kant s cosmopolitan doctrine and. Stoic cosmopolitanism in its various guises was enormously persuasive throughout the grecoroman world. Is it still possible to uphold international hospitality and justice in the face of increasing nationalism and civil strife in so many countries. Aristotle, stoicism and cosmopolitan political thought. Download pdf save cite this item table of contents. This chapter takes a critical look at the conventional identification of cosmopolitanism with europe. In this careful and insightful book, pauline kleingeld reconstructs kants cosmopolitanism, placing him in dialogue with historical contemporaries including christoph wieland, anacharsis cloots, georg forster, dietrich hegewisch, and novalis, and with several presentday thinkers john rawls, jurgen habermas, and thomas pogge. Kants idea for a universal history with a cosmopolitan aim. The period since 1989 has, however, seen a strong resurgence of interest in cosmopolitan themes. Paul guyer, leading kant philosopher and is considered one of the leading experts who understands immanuel kant, made a very interesting lecture and gave a very brief summation of kant and his contributionsthoughts to stoic philosophy. Immanuel kant provides a philosophical justification for cosmopolitanism in education and for internationalism in foreign policy. The claim that deleuze stands within a cosmopolitan tradition stretching back to the stoics is a striking one, especially when one bears in mind deleuze.
Nov 17, 2017 stoic cosmopolitanism should not be taken to imply that the ideal human society resembles a beehive, where individuality is subsumed for the benefit of the group. In modern thought, the german philosopher immanuel kant proposed a version of cosmopolitanism oriented around a law of universal hospitality that would. I argue that therapeutic cosmopolitanism is both the original and best way of being a worldcitizen. Pragmatic pluralism argues for situated and localized forms of cooperation between state and nonstate actors, particularly religious groups and organizations, that may not share the secular, juridical understandings of rights, persons, and obligations common to contemporary cosmopolitan theory. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading cosmopolitanism. Nussbaum kant and stoic cosmopolitanism free download as pdf file. Colish, the stoic tradition from antiquity to the early middle ages 2 vols. Cosmopolitanism and classical realism as morally defensible theories. Both kants cosmopolitanism and bhabhas vernacular cosmopolitanism are rooted in real conditions of largescale political power, and both types emerge in the consciousness. Two futures of cosmopolitanism by otto spijkers ssrn. Chapter 2 kant s cosmopolitan law and the idea of a cosmopolitan constitution. Stoic cosmopolitanism and business practice 20 second cosmopolitanism.
Cosmopolitanism is an emerging theme in studies of global justice and provides a meeting point between theorists of international law, political science, political cosmopolitanism, in international relations, school of thought in which the essence of international society is defined in terms of social bonds that link people, stoic cosmopolitanism in. The stoic invention of cosmopolitan politics1 eric brown department of philosophy washington university in st. Aristotle, stoicism and cosmopolitan political thought core. Comparing stoic and confucian cosmopolitanism springerlink. It is only in theory that their disenfranchisement gives rise to a type of consciousness, the minoritarian perspective, that is the root of their cosmopolitanism. Cosmopolite in ancient greece meant citizen of the world. Cosmopolitanism s roots are found in stoic philosophers such as. Then i shall turn to a thousand plateaus, and suggest the ways in which deleuze and guattari. University of groningen cosmopolitanism kleingeld, pauline. Greek stoic and kantian heritages as citizen of the world and engages itself with multiple. Recognizing this, his stoic successors held, we should not allow differences of nationality or class or. The peoples of the earth have thus entered in varying degrees into a universal community, and it has developed to the point where a violation of laws in one part of the world is felt everywhere.
Drawing on examples of treatment of minority groups in europe, he skilfully and accessibly probes the thinking that underlies much of the practice, and rhetoric, that informs cosmopolitanism. Is kantian ethics a type of non virtue oriented stoicism. This study examines ethical and political conditions concerning cosmopolitanism, and argues that radical generosity is a key condition for the possibility of cosmopolitanism. Some commentators try to assimilate kant s ethics to views like those of aristotle or the stoics, which are less strongly deontological and antiteleological than kant s are conventionally taken to be. The idea of a cosmopolitan law is therefore not fantastic and overstrained. Stoicism and cosmopolitanism although the term cosmopolitan, literally, worldcitizen, was used by greeks earlier than the stoic philosophers who started with zeno c.
Indeed, modern cosmopolitanism is always regarded as a successor of stoicism and kant, while confucianism is sometimes criticized by. On the contrary, the stoics were keen defenders of human freedom and very much valued the independence of individual agents. Cosmopolitanism has a collective aspect, theorized among others by durkheim, and an individualcentered aspect, elaborated particularly by kant. In part, this success can be explained by noting how cosmopolitan the world at.
Kant as a historical example, however, i propose two adjustments to our. The origins of ancient cosmopolitanism are traditionally attributed to diogenes the cynic. Kants theory of cosmopolitanism and hegels critique. Kant and stoic cosmopolitanism, the journal of political. Democracy democracy problem and perspectives pdf free download. They conclude that national boundaries have little or no moral relevance. The state of mind reflectedin cosmopolitan calls to develop new ways. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it.
Kant and contemporary liberal cosmopolitanism article pdf available in synthesis philosophica 16124. Cynic and stoic philosophers spoke of cosmopolitanism both to indicate their freedom from the narrow limits of their homeland and to affirm their participation in a larger political milieu. This is a moderate stoic cosmopolitanism, and empire made the doctrine very easy for many romans by identifying the roman patria with the cosmopolis itself. Following the thinking of stoic cosmopolitanism, which went from the stoics, through kant, to secretarygeneral kofi annan, one can say that a. I was talking with one of my philosophy professors about seneca and my interest in stoicism. Roth, 2010, supplying both a goal and the state of mind needed to reach it. Kant and stoic cosmopolitanism stoicism cosmopolitanism. Is kantian ethics a type of nonvirtue oriented stoicism. In his discussion of the idea of a cosmopolitan law, kant evolves the moral philosophy enshrined in stoic thought to a political philosophy complemented by the.
Global age cosmopolitanism 28 globalism and modernity 29. Like other intellectual fields, cosmopolitanism today is partly constructed through narrations of its history, which debate and define what is living and dead in previous forms of cosmopolitan thinking. A term of antique provenance, cosmopolitanism has developed and cohered into a critical concept in contemporary social and cultural analysis. Kant 22 kantian cosmopolitanism and business practice 24 third cosmopolitanism. Contemporary cosmopolitan thought is rich and diverse, encompassing a broad range of themes and issues. One should always behave so as to treat with equal respect the. Kant s embedded cosmopolitanism is a valuable source for students of political philosophy and kant s ethics. John sellars rp 142 marapr 2007 deleuze and cosmopolitanism. A comparison chen yudan four centuries after the signing of the peace of westphalia, an interstate system with national sovereignty as its fundamental principle, spread from europe into the entire world. It will be my contention that kantand, through him, seneca, marcus aurelius, and above all cicero present us with a challenge that is at once noble and practical. Lively debates about narratives of historical progress, the conditions for international justice, and the implications of globalisation have prompted a renewed interest in kant s idea for a universal history with a cosmopolitan aim. Ethics in a world of strangers issues of our time kindle edition by appiah, kwame anthony. The kant brought out here turns out to be very different from current mainstream appropriations, which erroneously consider him one of the founding fathers of the new cosmopolitanism.
Paul guyers thoughts on kant as a stoic paul guyer, leading kant philosopher and is considered one of the leading experts who understands immanuel kant, made a very interesting lecture and gave a very brief summation of kant and his contributionsthoughts to stoic philosophy. University of groningen six varieties of cosmopolitanism in. Cosmopolitanism as a theory holds strong ideational visions of universal moral coverage where the individual serves as the basic unit of concern, and determine that moral agents are compelled to act in pursuit of greater wellbeing for the least advantaged in society. The term cosmopolitan occurs frequently throughout kant s political writings, often in close proximity to classical citations and references. The philosophy of immanuel kant alfred weber i mmanuel kant,2 born in konigsberg, prussia, 1724, was the son of plain people. Chapter 7 kants cosmopolitanism and current philosophical debates. Late stoic cosmopolitanism wellwritten books can turn you into something different from others, because the article will keep you from lazing around and maintaining your current quality, allowing you to feel relaxed and let your body and soul relax. Drawing upon the stoic theory of incorporeals, deleuze outlines an ontological surface. Kant and stoic cosmopolitanism nussbaum 1997 journal of.
Kant does not make attainment of good they key notion in his ethics, as herman and guyer in quite different ways think he does. In this careful and insightful book, pauline kleingeld reconstructs kant s cosmopolitanism, placing him in dialogue with historical contemporaries including christoph wieland, anacharsis cloots, georg forster, dietrich hegewisch, and novalis, and with several presentday thinkers john rawls, jurgen habermas, and thomas pogge. Wideranging debates exist concerning cosmopolitanism as a stance and as an object of study. But neither imperialism nor a literal interpretation of worldcitizenship is required for the philosophical point. Read online stoicism and cosmopolitanism book pdf free download link book now. Downloaded from the university of groningenumcg research database pure. They frequently appeal to eighteenthcentury cosmopoli. Kant and stoic cosmopolitanism nussbaum 1997 journal. Against this background, kants cosmopolitan vision stands out as more. According to a number of contemporary philosophers, the moral demands to care for those of the same nationality are not more pressing than the demands to care for those of a different nation, at least in regard to basic needs and rights. Six varieties of cosmopolitanism in late eighteenthcentury germany pauline kleingeld in part as a response to the current resurgence of nationalist sentiment in many parts of the world, several authors have recently sought to revive the legacy of cosmopolitanism. There has been an explosion of interest in recent years in cosmopolitanism, as both political philosophy and object of sociological investigation. Kwame anthony appiah is professor of afroamerican studies and philosophy at harvard university.
Ethics and politics of cosmopolitanism by ali kashani this inquiry is about the following question. Cosmopolitanism is the ideology that all human beings belong to a single community, based on a shared morality. The aim of this paper is to find out what happened to two different variations of cosmopolitan thinking over the course of history. Download stoicism and cosmopolitanism book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf. Palmer cato institute abstract many critics of increasing freedom of trade and of movement, and the phenomena of cosmopolitanism and globalization that result from such freedom, insist that the consequence of greater trade and movement is a net loss of identity. Cultural, moral, and political find, read and cite all the. Deleuze and cosmopolitanism radical philosophy archive. Aristotle, stoicism and cosmopolitan political thought a paper presented to a conference on the theme of. From kant to the idea of a cosmopolitan constitution.
In origin, cosmopolitanism suggests the establishment of a cosmo polis or world state for all of humanity. Cosmopolitanisms roots are found in stoic philosophers such as seneca, marcus. Kant s cosmopolitanism has strongly influencedsubsequent cosmopolitan thought and philosophers palmer, 2003. The term is similar to globalism and internationalism. I post this lecture having not listened to all of it, but i see. View or download all content the institution has subscribed to. While the nationstate system has always been the core element in practice, reflections of. To do so, i summarize the present taxonomy of cosmopolitanisms and show how therapeutic cosmopolitanism contrasts with these options. Kant s perpetual peace is a profound defense of cosmopolitan values. Stoic cosmopolitanism and confucian cosmopolitanism.
Nussbaum, kant and stoic cosmopolitanism philpapers. Cambridge core history of philosophy kant and cosmopolitanism by pauline kleingeld. Aristotle on the one hand and the cosmopolitanism of the stoics on the other. Kants idea for a universal history with a cosmopolitan. After pursuing his studies at the university of his native city 17401746, kant became a private tutor. However, the daunting quantity and variable quality of the available research exploring the. See eric brown, stoic cosmopolitanism and the political life ph. Basedow, rousseau, and cosmopolitan education, studies in philosophy and education on deepdyve, the largest online rental service for scholarly research with thousands of academic publications available at your fingertips. On the contrary, the stoics were keen defenders of human freedom and very. Globalization, cosmopolitanism, and personal identity. His paternal grandparents emigrated to germany from the fatherland of hume. Seen both as a symbolic entity with a long, continuous history, and as a set of crossborder institutions, europe may be linked with conventional cosmopolitan ideals of world peace, intercultural tolerance and the global legal regulation of social life. In the empirical sociological literature, there is a strong tendency to present western cosmopolitan thought as purely theoretical in nature, devoid of empirical referents and underpinnings. Conflict and cosmopolitanism in plato and the stoics.
1436 507 866 709 452 1543 67 426 1286 484 726 704 1211 1309 1513 85 486 1324 583 633 793 589 934 1147 181 669 1319 491 803 1487 1469 219 460 543 819 554 757 742 176